I was taught that in general practice its best not to try to beat the compiler, at least until its proven to be stupid. So in general, and since I was told that its generally only used as a suggestion to the compiler, the inline tag has never been a priority for me to use because I was taught that the compiler is pretty good when it comes to understanding the trade offs your system will have to make when it comes to inlining vs. looped calls to a function pointer for example.
But then I just read that functions cannot be inlined unless they are defined in the header file because otherwise the compiler won't see it when it starts to work on other header and cpp files (read from . I did some more research and I found that some people were saying that this is the old way things worked and that modern compilers perform "Whole Program Optimization" or "Link-Time Code Generation" which is responsible for the construction of the obj files that I'm used to seeing which can then be linked together and optimized further such as allowing the compiler to see functions in the obj file that were once "hidden" in the cpp file and then inline optimize them where appropriate. This sounds great but I'm wondering which source to trust and was wondering if I could get an additional opinion on the matter.
On the other hand I was reading up on header only implementations and how they tend to be used in libraries to increase compiler optimizations and was wondering if its was also a standard practice in game development or if it was typical to separate declaration and implementation into different files when developing a game engine.
Thanks in advance for the help.