I'm making a mobile rpg game, an infinite one where there is a loot system like Diablo 3. Weapons have attack and speed, armor pieces have a resistance value (not percentage).

The formula I'm using is:

float realDamage = SkillDmg * BaseDamage / ( BaseDamage + Defense )

The results are good, the daamge gets bigger if the defense gets lower and it doesn't exponentially go up because of the division between ( BaseDamage + Defense ).

Lets say I have a sword with 1.0 attack speed that deals 50 damage. Thats 50 dps, and I have a dagger that I want it to attack faster, but of course deal less damage, to maintain the dps the logic says that if the daggers attack speed is doubled, the damage needs to be halfed (2.0 speed with 25 dmg ). But using the formula above you'll see that the actual real damage DPS is lower than the sword.

Iv'e solved this by making the dagger not do 25 damage but a bit more, doing some calculations I can make the real dps be the same to balance things. In this case the dagger at 2.0 speed would need to deal 32 damage to be the same real damage dps as the sword.

However, I want to display the DPS number on weapons. If I just display the daggers DPS as 32 dmg * 2 attackspeed it's going to be 64 dps, compared to the sword 50 dps, one will clearly say that the dagger is better, but of course it's not.

Possible solutions? Change the initial damage formula? If so to which one? Lets assume I don't change the formula, is there any solution? I really don't like having to trick the dagger to deal more damage than half to make it even...

I'd really wish I'd know the damage formula for diablo 3. I know that diablo 3 weapons DPS it's simply base damage * attack speed.

Edit:

Lets assume defense = 50 and normal attack (skillDmg = baseDmg)

Sword 1.0 attack speed dealing 50 dmg -> real damage hit=  50 * 50 / ( 50 + 50 ) = **25 dmg** = 25 dps

Dagger 2.0 attack speed dealing 32 dmg -> real damage hit = 32 * 32 / ( 32 + 50 ) = **12.5 dmg** = 25 dps

Sword item, lets display the actual sword dps, 50 * 1.0 = **50 dps**
Dagger item, lets display the dagger dps, 32 * 2.0 = **64 dps** (SHOULD BE THE SAME)

I'm making a mobile rpg game, an infinite one where there is a loot system like Diablo 3. Weapons have attack and speed, armor pieces have a resistance value (not percentage).

The formula I'm using is:

float realDamage = SkillDmg * BaseDamage / ( BaseDamage + Defense )

The results are good, the damage gets bigger if the defense gets lower and it doesn't exponentially go up because of the division between ( BaseDamage + Defense ).

Lets say I have a sword with 1.0 attack speed that deals 50 damage. Thats 50 dps, and I have a dagger that I want it to attack faster, but of course deal less damage, to maintain the dps the logic says that if the daggers attack speed is doubled, the damage needs to be halfed (2.0 speed with 25 dmg ). But using the formula above you'll see that the actual real damage DPS is lower than the sword.

Iv'e solved this by making the dagger not do 25 damage but a bit more, doing some calculations I can make the real dps be the same to balance things. In this case the dagger at 2.0 speed would need to deal 32 damage to be the same real damage dps as the sword.

However, I want to display the DPS number on weapons. If I just display the daggers DPS as 32 dmg * 2 attackspeed it's going to be 64 dps, compared to the sword 50 dps, one will clearly say that the dagger is better, but of course it's not.

Possible solutions? Change the initial damage formula? If so to which one? Lets assume I don't change the formula, is there any solution? I really don't like having to trick the dagger to deal more damage than half to make it even...

I'd really wish I'd know the damage formula for diablo 3. I know that diablo 3 weapons DPS it's simply base damage * attack speed.

Edit:

Lets assume defense = 50 and normal attack (skillDmg = baseDmg)

Sword 1.0 attack speed dealing 50 dmg -> real damage hit=  50 * 50 / ( 50 + 50 ) = **25 dmg** = 25 dps

Dagger 2.0 attack speed dealing 32 dmg -> real damage hit = 32 * 32 / ( 32 + 50 ) = **12.5 dmg** = 25 dps

Sword item, lets display the actual sword dps, 50 * 1.0 = **50 dps**
Dagger item, lets display the dagger dps, 32 * 2.0 = **64 dps** (SHOULD BE THE SAME)

I'm making a mobile rpg game, an infinite one where there is a loot system like Diablo 3. Weapons have attack and speed, armor pieces have a resistance value (not percentage).

The formula I'm using is:

float realDamage = SkillDmg * BaseDamage / ( BaseDamage + Defense )

The results are good, the daamge gets bigger if the defense gets lower and it doesn't exponentially go up because of the division between ( BaseDamage + Defense ).

Lets say I have a sword with 1.0 attack speed that deals 50 damage. Thats 50 dps, and I have a dagger that I want it to attack faster, but of course deal less damage, to maintain the dps the logic says that if the daggers attack speed is doubled, the damage needs to be halfed (2.0 speed with 25 dmg ). But using the formula above you'll see that the actual real damage DPS is lower than the sword.

Iv'e solved this by making the dagger not do 25 damage but a bit more, doing some calculations I can make the real dps be the same to balance things. In this case the dagger at 2.0 speed would need to deal 32 damage to be the same real damage dps as the sword.

However, I want to display the DPS number on weapons. If I just display the daggers DPS as 32 dmg * 2 attackspeed it's going to be 64 dps, compared to the sword 50 dps, one will clearly say that the dagger is better, but of course it's not.

Possible solutions? Change the initial damage formula? If so to which one? Lets assume I don't change the formula, is there any solution? I really don't like having to trick the dagger to deal more damage than half to make it even...

I'd really wish I'd know the damage formula for diablo 3. I know that diablo 3 weapons DPS it's simply base damage * attack speed.

Edit: Lets assume defense = 50

Sword 1.0 attack speed dealing 50 dmg -> real damage hit= 50 * 50 / ( 50 + 50 ) = 25 dmg = 25 dps

Dagger 2.0 attack speed dealing 32 dmg -> real damage hit = 32 * 32 / ( 32 + 50 ) = 12.5 dmg = 25 dps

Sword item, lets display the actual sword dps, 50 * 1.0 = 50 dps Dagger item, lets display the dagger dps, 32 * 2.0 = 64 dps (SHOULD BE THE SAME)

I'm making a mobile rpg game, an infinite one where there is a loot system like Diablo 3. Weapons have attack and speed, armor pieces have a resistance value (not percentage).

The formula I'm using is:

float realDamage = SkillDmg * BaseDamage / ( BaseDamage + Defense )

The results are good, the daamge gets bigger if the defense gets lower and it doesn't exponentially go up because of the division between ( BaseDamage + Defense ).

Lets say I have a sword with 1.0 attack speed that deals 50 damage. Thats 50 dps, and I have a dagger that I want it to attack faster, but of course deal less damage, to maintain the dps the logic says that if the daggers attack speed is doubled, the damage needs to be halfed (2.0 speed with 25 dmg ). But using the formula above you'll see that the actual real damage DPS is lower than the sword.

Iv'e solved this by making the dagger not do 25 damage but a bit more, doing some calculations I can make the real dps be the same to balance things. In this case the dagger at 2.0 speed would need to deal 32 damage to be the same real damage dps as the sword.

However, I want to display the DPS number on weapons. If I just display the daggers DPS as 32 dmg * 2 attackspeed it's going to be 64 dps, compared to the sword 50 dps, one will clearly say that the dagger is better, but of course it's not.

Possible solutions? Change the initial damage formula? If so to which one? Lets assume I don't change the formula, is there any solution? I really don't like having to trick the dagger to deal more damage than half to make it even...

I'd really wish I'd know the damage formula for diablo 3. I know that diablo 3 weapons DPS it's simply base damage * attack speed.

Edit:

Lets assume defense = 50 and normal attack (skillDmg = baseDmg)

Sword 1.0 attack speed dealing 50 dmg -> real damage hit=  50 * 50 / ( 50 + 50 ) = **25 dmg** = 25 dps

Dagger 2.0 attack speed dealing 32 dmg -> real damage hit = 32 * 32 / ( 32 + 50 ) = **12.5 dmg** = 25 dps

Sword item, lets display the actual sword dps, 50 * 1.0 = **50 dps**
Dagger item, lets display the dagger dps, 32 * 2.0 = **64 dps** (SHOULD BE THE SAME)