I started learning OpenGL. I got to a point I want to import some "real" objects. After "Googling" I decided I will go with OBJ file for start, since it is simple to understand, and there are plenty of tutorials on how to read them properly.

I have from university access to 3DS Max 2012. So I tried to create very simple model (just deformated cube) and exporting it using OBJ file, just to vertices and triangles for the moment, without textures, so I can examine its structure by myself. But if I imported it right back to 3DS from OBJ file, now it renders somewhat strange, like its smoothen, and with lightsource, even I have none in scene. But the geometry, its wireframe is intact.

So I thought maybe it is problem of exporting only vertices and triangles so I downloaded Enterprise-D model from internet, exported with everything on (normals, textures everything), and again imported it. Now, some polygons are missing.

So, I want to ask, am I doing something terribly wrong, or is there some incompatibility issue between .max and .obj file ? Even it is only simple textured model without any lightsources, animation etc.? Thanks.

Edit: I tried objects with MeshLab, the first, deformated cube was absolutelly OK. But still bothers me that 3DS Max doesen´t render it properly. In Enterprise-D model, there are polygons missing even in MeshLab. I uploaded rar archive with .max model of Enterprise, same .obj model exported from 3DS, and obj model of deformated cube. Download here (2.5 MB, filesonic).

  • \$\begingroup\$ Can you upload the OBJ somewhere so we can test it? I would also try to load the OBJ with another software, to see how it looks. MeshLab meshlab.sourceforge.net is a great option. \$\endgroup\$ – Dan Nov 12 '11 at 12:11

The first problem you described sounds like the normals getting smoothed. I notice your Test.obj file was exported without normals; when it was re-imported, 3DS would auto-generate normals for it and probably assumed they were to be smooth. In this case exporting with normals should fix the problem.

As for the Enterprise model, I opened it in Maya and saw some odd-looking, possibly malformed faces on the bottom, but no actual holes that I could find. Are you sure the problem is not with the original model?

  • \$\begingroup\$ Thanks. Well, In 3DS Max, it looks alright, even non-textured. Maybe it is using some tool obj exporter cannot convert to faces. Anyway, I found different model and its OK. Thanks :) \$\endgroup\$ – Vit Nov 13 '11 at 10:31

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.