# NPC Melee fighting movement issue

So i have been struggling with this for ages and I have now decided to reach out for help.

The Problem:

The game has two NPCs for reference we will call them "Ally" and "Enemy"

Ally and Enemy each have their own weapon:

• Ally has a sword with a reach 0.1 - 2 meters

• Enemy has a long sword that has a reach of 0.5 - 3 meters.

Now these two NPC's wish to fight each other. They need to make sure that they stay within the reach of their weapons while also making sure that they don't bump into each other.

For this I attempted the following algorithm:

bool shouldMove = false;
Vector3 lToTarget = Target.transform.position - transform.position;
lToTarget.y = 0f;

Vector3 lToTargetDirection = lToTarget.normalized;
float lToTargetDistance = lToTarget.magnitude;
float lRange = MinMeleeReach + MaxRange;
if (!shouldMove && lToTargetDistance > lRange + 1f)
{
shouldMove = true;
}

if (shouldMove && lToTargetDistance <= Mathf.Max(lRange))
{
shouldMove = false;
}

if (shouldMove)
{
float lSpeed = Mathf.Min(MovementSpeed * Time.deltaTime, lToTargetDistance);
transform.position = transform.position + (lToTargetDirection * lSpeed);
}


Now if they should not move then they would attack their target.

However as you might have guessed this has an issue:

The agent tries to keep his distance to the max of his range!

This sadly causes the agents to bug out in a way where they are never close enough to attack each other resulting in something that looks like this:

So i thought to my self how can i change this behavior.

I came up with another idea which sadly had the same problem this time using navmesh agent:

Vector3 direction =
(transform.position - Target.position).normalized;
Vector3 finalPosition = Target.position + direction * maxRange;
navMeshAgent.SetDestination(finalPosition);


Again sort of same behavior, however, this time they just kept their distance and if the other agent came to close they would start moving backward. Which basically meant that they would move back to the end of the world.

So this is where I am at right now. I have attempted to google this issue however without much luck.

So i am really praying that you guys have an answer for me :)

• If they only need to make sure they don't bump into each other, then why not to check only "bumping" range? That is, their collision shape range plus some optional bias value. Jul 13, 2019 at 12:13
• @Ocelot This is a test scene there will be more units on the battlefield so they need to keep their distance Jul 13, 2019 at 12:21
• This is confusing, make sure to include all the cases you want to handle before asking for a solution. Maybe you will come up with your own in the process. Jul 13, 2019 at 13:47
• ... ignoring the development issues, it should be noted that "bumping" your opponent is a wonderful tactic, especially in certain formation strategies. Aug 11, 2020 at 23:49