I am looking for a collision detection solution for use when 2d screen wrapping. Specifically, when the image is split between the right and left side I can only detect a collision for a limited area.

For example, the program detects the collision when the rectangle intersects the circle in the first image. However, it doesn't in the second image. I am using the Rectangle.Instersects method to check for the collision in both cases.



I used the screen-wrapping solution at the following link: How to create a 2D region where sprites are automatically wrapped?

However, since I am not using the physics engine, I am not using the related solution at: How to create a very specific kind of joint in Farseer?

I am aware of the following question: https://stackoverflow.com/questions/8679304/wrapping-drawn-image-in-xna-4-0, and incorporated part of the code to reset the draw rectangle's position when wrapping for both sprites:

 // reset draw rectangle for wrapping
        if (drawRectangle.X < -sprite.Width)
            drawRectangle.X += parentWindowWidth;
        if (drawRectangle.X > parentWindowWidth)
            drawRectangle.X -= parentWindowWidth;
        if (drawRectangle.Y < -sprite.Height)
            drawRectangle.Y += parentWindowHeight;
        if (drawRectangle.Y > parentWindowHeight)
            drawRectangle.Y -= parentWindowHeight;

This post also says that I have to check for the collision in the two separate positions, but I am having trouble doing so.

Any suggestions?


I had to solve this issue a long time ago, and all I did was do:

  • One normal collision check.
  • One where I shifted everything up one "world-height" (aka screen height)
  • Shift down
  • Shift left one "world-width" (screen width)
  • Shift right
  • Up and Right
  • Up and Left
  • Down and Right
  • Down and Left


if(x + width  > test.x && x < test.x + test.width &&
   y + height > test.y && y < test.y + test.height)
else if(x + width  > test.x + worldWidth && x < test.x + test.width + worldWidth &&
        y + height > test.y && y < test.y + test.height)
.... 7 more times

Seems cumbersome and inefficient, and it probably is, but it's the easiest & most straight-forward way to solve this issue.

Below, I've drawn your playable area in white, and the possible collision zones in other colours in the diagram below:

Torus collision example

In this example, I have left the circle in place (x and y in example code), and compared it against your squiggle of colours in all 9 possible configurations listed above. As a visual demonstration, I've drawn all 9 possibilities.

This should get you pointed in the right direction.

Other torus-world tips I can provide are:

  • You're going to need to detect when an object crosses these boundaries and draw the same thing up to 4 times if it's straddling a corner.
  • Shortest paths (eg, Homing missiles) will need to compare all 9 routes to the target.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.