Take the 2-minute tour ×
Game Development Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for professional and independent game developers. It's 100% free, no registration required.

I have a perspective projection. When the user clicks on the screen, I want to compute the ray between the near and far planes that projects from the mouse point, so I can do some ray intersection code with my world.

I am using my own matrix and vector and ray classes and they all work as expected.

However, when I try and convert the ray to world coordinates my far always ends up as 0,0,0 and so my ray goes from the mouse click to the centre of the object space, rather than through it. (The x and y coordinates of near and far are identical, they differ only in the z coordinates where they are negatives of each other)

GLint vp[4];
glGetIntegerv(GL_VIEWPORT,vp);
matrix_t mv, p;
glGetFloatv(GL_MODELVIEW_MATRIX,mv.f);
glGetFloatv(GL_PROJECTION_MATRIX,p.f);
const matrix_t inv = (mv*p).inverse();
const float
    unit_x = (2.0f*((float)(x-vp[0])/(vp[2]-vp[0])))-1.0f,
    unit_y = 1.0f-(2.0f*((float)(y-vp[1])/(vp[3]-vp[1])));
const vec_t near(vec_t(unit_x,unit_y,-1)*inv);
const vec_t far(vec_t(unit_x,unit_y,1)*inv);
ray = ray_t(near,far-near);

What have I got wrong? (How do you unproject the mouse-point?)

share|improve this question
    
Just out of curiosity, is there a reason you aren't using the built-in GL_SELECTION mode? (info here) –  Ricket Feb 24 '11 at 15:03
    
@Ricket Isn't it deprecated? Don't know, but quite sure. –  Notabene Feb 24 '11 at 18:22
    
Are the x and y in pixels? that would be the problem... –  Notabene Feb 24 '11 at 18:28
    
And you are multiplying vec3 by matrix4. That is not good... what number goes into 4th position when you do vec_t(1st,2nd,3th,4th)? –  Notabene Feb 24 '11 at 19:13
    
@notebene Wow, I guess it is, I had no clue. This discussion is good and provides an alternative which I'll have to look into, and now I'm REALLY hoping for a good answer to this question. –  Ricket Feb 24 '11 at 19:18

2 Answers 2

up vote 9 down vote accepted

I recently had to solve this myself for a WebGL application. I've attached the complete source code, but incase it doesn't work right off the bat for you here are some debugging tips:

  1. Don't debug your unproject method in your game. If possible, try to write unit-test style tests to make it easier to isolate what is going wrong.
  2. Be sure to print the output rays for both the near and far clipping planes.
  3. Remember that matrix math is NOT commutative. A x C != C x A. Double check your math.

Also, to reply to some comments above, you almost never want to use OpenGL's selection APIs. That helps you pick existing items, like if you were creating a menu, however it fails to perform most real-world scenarios like 3D model editing. Where you need to add geometry as a result of the click.

Here is my implementation. There is nothing magic going on here. Just JavaScript and Google's Closure library.

gluUnProject

/**
 * Port of gluUnProject. Unprojects a 2D screen coordinate into the model-view
 * coordinates.
 * @param {Number} winX The window point for the x value.
 * @param {Number} winY The window point for the y value.
 * @param {Number} winZ The window point for the z value. This should range
 *    between 0 and 1. 0 meaning the near clipping plane and 1 for the far.
 * @param {goog.math.Matrix} modelViewMatrix The model-view matrix.
 * @param {goog.math.Matrix} projectMatrix The projection matrix.
 * @param {Array.<Number>} view the viewport coordinate array.
 * @param {Array.<Number>} objPos the model point result.
 * @return {Boolean} Whether or not the unprojection was successful.
 */
octorok.math.Matrix.gluUnProject = function(winX, winY, winZ,
                        modelViewMatrix, projectionMatrix,
                        viewPort, objPos) {
  // Compute the inverse of the perspective x model-view matrix.
  /** @type {goog.math.Matrix} */
  var transformMatrix =
    projectionMatrix.multiply(modelViewMatrix).getInverse();

  // Transformation of normalized coordinates (-1 to 1).
  /** @type {Array.<Number>} */
  var inVector = [
    (winX - viewPort[0]) / viewPort[2] * 2.0 - 1.0,
    (winY - viewPort[1]) / viewPort[3] * 2.0 - 1.0,
    2.0 * winZ - 1.0,
    1.0 ];

  // Now transform that vector into object coordinates.
  /** @type {goog.math.Matrix} */
  // Flip 1x4 to 4x1. (Alternately use different matrix ctor.
  var inMatrix = new goog.math.Matrix([ inVector ]).getTranspose();
  /** @type {goog.math.Matrix} */
  var resultMtx = transformMatrix.multiply(inMatrix);
  /** @type {Array.<Number>} */
  var resultArr = [
    resultMtx.getValueAt(0, 0),
    resultMtx.getValueAt(1, 0),
    resultMtx.getValueAt(2, 0),
    resultMtx.getValueAt(3, 0) ];

  if (resultArr[3] == 0.0) {
    return false;
  }

  // Invert to normalize x, y, and z values.
  resultArr[3] = 1.0 / resultArr[3];

  objPos[0] = resultArr[0] * resultArr[3];
  objPos[1] = resultArr[1] * resultArr[3];
  objPos[2] = resultArr[2] * resultArr[3];

  return true;
};

Usage

  this.sys.event_mouseClicked = function(event) {
    // Relative x and y are computed via magic by SystemModule.
    // Should range from 0 .. viewport width/height.
    var winX = event.relativeX;
    var winY = event.relativeY;
    window.console.log('Camera at [' + me.camera.position_ + ']');
    window.console.log('Clicked [' + winX + ', ' + winY + ']');

    // viewportOriginX, viewportOriginY, viewportWidth, viewportHeight
    var viewPort = [0, 0, event.viewPortWidth, event.viewPortHeight];
    var objPos = [];  // out parameter.

    // The camera's model-view matrix is the result of gluLookAt.
    var modelViewMatrix = me.camera.getCameraMatrix();
    // The perspective matrix is the result of gluPerspective.
    var perspectiveMatrix = pMatrix.get();

    // Ray start
    var result1 = octorok.math.Matrix.gluUnProject(
      winX, winY, 0.0,
      modelViewMatrix, perspectiveMatrix,
      viewPort, objPos);
    window.console.log('Seg start: ' + objPos + ' (result:' + result1 + ')');

    // Ray end
    var result2 = octorok.math.Matrix.gluUnProject(
      winX, winY, 1.0,
      modelViewMatrix, perspectiveMatrix,
      viewPort, objPos);
    window.console.log('Seg end: ' + objPos + ' (result:' + result2 + ')');
  };
};
share|improve this answer
    
In what case does if (resultArr[3] == 0.0) evaluate to true? –  Halsafar Jul 16 '13 at 17:37

I dont see any problems with your code. So i only have some suggestions:

unit_x = (2.0f*((float)(x-vp[0])/(vp[2]-vp[0])))-1.0f,
unit_y = (2.0f*((float)(y-vp[1])/(vp[3]-vp[1])))-1.0f;

And trying to change matrix multiplacation to (p*mv).inverse();. Just because glMatrices are nutaraly transposed in memory. (this is one big maybe, sorry)

Another raycasting
Unprojecting is not only way how to get ray from the pixel. This is my code for raycaster:

//works for right handed coordinates. So it is opengl friendly.
float mx = (float)((pixel.x - screenResolution.x * 0.5) * (1.0 / screenResolution.x) * camera.fovX * 0.5);
float my = (float)((pixel.y - screenResolution.y * 0.5) * (1.0 / screenResolution.x) * camera.fovX * 0.5);
float4 dx = cameraRight * mx;
float4 dy = cameraUp * my;

float3 dir = normalize(cameraDir + (dx + dy).xyz * 2.0);

You can get cameraRight, Up and Direction from view matrix (which is mostly useful in shader) View matrix in opengl

Color Picking
Color picking is a technique where you render every clickable object with another (solid) color and then read the value of color at clicked point. It worked as GL_SELECTION in opengl. But it is deprecated now. But color picking is easy to code as 1 additional render pass.

Use frame buffer and render to texture with same resolution as screen resolution, use simple shader which just return color in fragment shader. After "color pass", read the value from a texture addressing with clickedPoint x and y. Find object with color which you read. Easy and quite fast.

share|improve this answer

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.