Tell me more ×
Game Development Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for professional and independent game developers. It's 100% free, no registration required.
up vote 8 down vote favorite

I'm making a simple 2D XNA game for Xbox 360. My game can be paused by pressing the Start button on the Xbox controller. While paused, a simple menu pops up with options like Resume and Exit to Title Screen. The way I've currently programmed it, the menu options can only be selected with the A button on the Xbox controller, but I've found that I intuitively want to press Start to resume the action again.

I think it's a given that Start pauses the game and displays the pause menu, but once the pause menu is displayed, I can think of 3 options for dealing with input:

  • Menu options can be selected with the A button. Start does nothing.

  • Menu options can be selected with the A button or the Start button.

  • Menu options can be selected with the A button. Start resumes gameplay regardless of which menu option is selected.

What's the best control scheme to pause a game and accept input on a pause screen menu? Are there any guidelines or standards to help choose between these options?

share|improve this question
Microsoft requires the following in XBLA games and should be put in place in an indie game, I know it doesn't answer the question but I thought you might want to know it. > Resume Game >Help & Options [submenu] >> How to Play >> Controls >> Settings >> Credits (if applicable) >Leaderboards (not required on indie game) >Achievements (not applicable on indie game) >Save Game (if applicable) >Exit Game – Matt Jensen Dec 3 '11 at 4:28

1 Answer

up vote 13 down vote accepted

As a gamer, I appreciate it when games use the following conventions:

  • I press Start to pause the game.
  • Unless it has some special function (like bringing up a secondary menu), I want the B button to unpause the game.
  • Same goes for Start button.
  • I want to move the selection with either the left thumbstick or the D-pad, and I want the selection to wrap. ie: If I am at the top of the list and press up, then it should go to the bottom.
  • 'A' button selects menu items.

Also, slightly unrelated, but when the game is paused, keep a timer and if there's no user input after 3-5 seconds or something please fade down the music and other continuously playing sound effects.

Update

Adding Trevor's comment in the answer because it's important:

An extra often-forgotten point: Any current controller vibration should be stopped as soon as the pause screen is opened. The vibration should NOT be resumed when leaving the pause screen.

share|improve this answer
8  
+1 for the sound fading suggestion. – William 'MindWorX' Mariager Dec 2 '11 at 19:32
3  
An extra often-forgotten point: Any current controller vibration should be stopped as soon as the pause screen is opened. The vibration should NOT be resumed when leaving the pause screen. Example: I'm caught in an explosion, triggering a few seconds of controller vibration. Before that vibration ends, I pause to go do other things. When I return and un-pause, I shouldn't feel any controller vibration from the explosion which occurred before the pause screen, but only from the next explosion or other vibration source that I encounter in the game. – Trevor Powell Dec 2 '11 at 23:04

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.